What Can I Do? – Experimental Perfume Club
By Emmanuelle Moeglin, Founder & Perfumer
In short
1
Check it has really gone: it may be renamed, regional or reformulated.
2
If you love it, buy sealed bottles carefully, and beware of fakes and old stock.
3
Then find a new scent from the same family, or create one of your own.
If your perfume has been discontinued, first check that it has really gone: many fragrances are reformulated, renamed or only sold in certain countries. If it has, you have three good options: buy the remaining stock carefully, find a new scent from the same fragrance family, or create one of your own that captures what you loved.
It happens to almost every perfume lover at some point. You go to replace a bottle you have worn for years and it is nowhere to be found. Here is what I advise, as a perfumer, when a favourite disappears.
Create your own
Luxe Blending Experience
One hour with a Blending Master at our Lab-Boutique in central London. Leave with your own scent.
Why do perfumes get discontinued?
Every year the market is flooded with thousands of new launches, and shelf space does not grow with them. Most brands now carry dozens of fragrances, so each new arrival pushes an older one out. A perfume that no longer sells well enough is the first to go.
Regulation plays a part too. Perfumes are cosmetics, and the rules on which materials can be used, and at what level, are updated regularly. When an old formula no longer complies, a brand can either rework it or let it go, and letting it go is often the easier route. A change of ownership can have the same effect: a new owner may prefer to build their own range rather than keep their predecessor’s.
A few fragrances escape the cycle. Chanel No. 5 has been sold since 1921 and CK One since 1994. They are the exception: most perfumes have a much shorter life.
Most perfumes are not discontinued because they are bad, but because the shelf is full.
01
Step 1
Is it really discontinued, or just reformulated?
Before you panic, check. Look on the brand’s own website and ask its customer service directly; they will usually tell you. Shop assistants and resellers do not always know.
A perfume can vanish from your usual shop while still existing elsewhere. It may have been renamed or repackaged, moved to the brand’s own boutiques, kept for travel retail, or sold only in certain countries. Some fragrances were limited editions from the start and were never meant to stay.
The opposite also happens: the name stays but the scent changes. Brands reformulate when a material is restricted or becomes hard to source. If your new bottle does not smell quite like your old one, that is very likely the reason, and an older bottle may be the only way back to the version you knew.
02
Step 2
Should you buy the last bottles?
If you love it, stocking up on a few bottles is reasonable. Do it carefully.
Beware of fakes.
Once a perfume is discontinued, counterfeits follow. Buy from reputable retailers where you can, and be wary of a price that is too low, packaging that looks slightly off or a seller who cannot show the batch code. Many brands print a batch code on the base of the bottle or the box, which can also tell you roughly when it was made.
Beware of old stock.
Perfume does not last forever. Light, heat and air slowly oxidise it. The fresh top notes go first, especially citrus: an oxidised perfume opens sharp, sour or flat, and the liquid may darken. An unopened bottle kept in its box ages far more slowly than one that has sat on a sunny shelf, so ask how it was stored, and think twice before paying a premium for a half-empty bottle of unknown history.
Keep bottles upright, capped and boxed, somewhere cool and dark.
Store it well.
Keep your bottles upright, with the cap on, in their box, somewhere cool and dark. A bedroom drawer or wardrobe is far kinder than a bathroom, where heat and humidity change through the day.
What was really in your perfume?
It is tempting to think the list of notes will lead you to a replacement. It helps, but it is not the formula. The notes you read online or on the box are a description, usually written for marketing rather than by the perfumer. A perfume can contain dozens of materials, sometimes more than a hundred, and a note of rose or jasmine may be an interpretation of the flower rather than the natural itself. Many notes, such as blackberry, do not exist as a single material at all: they are accords, small formulas of materials that together smell like the real thing.
The ingredient list on the box does not reveal much either. The formula is kept as a trade secret and appears simply as “parfum” or “fragrance”. The names you do see, such as linalool or limonene, are allergens that must be declared by law above a certain level.
A real formula holds far more than the notes on the box.
A formula can be analysed in a laboratory, usually by gas chromatography, which separates a perfume into its components so an expert can interpret them. It is never fully accurate. The same technique is used by companies selling copycat perfumes, or dupes. We do not recommend them, and we do not make them: copying takes from the people who spent months creating the original.
Try this at home
When someone tells me their perfume has gone, I suggest they start the way we do in the lab: identify the fragrance family. Every perfume belongs to a family and sub-family, whether that is woody amber, fresh citrus, powdery floral or green chypre. Once you know yours, search for it on a fragrance database such as Fragrantica or Parfumo. Both let you filter by family, by notes and by accords, so you can pull up a list of perfumes built on a similar architecture. You will never find an exact copy, but you will often find one that shares the character you loved.
Emmanuelle Moeglin
03
Step 3
How do I find a perfume similar to my discontinued one?
Start with its fragrance family and sub-family: a fresh citrus, a powdery floral, a woody amber, a green chypre. Perfumes from the same family share their main characteristics, so that is where your next favourite is most likely to be. Our guide to understanding your fragrance family explains how to place yours.
Fragrance communities and databases can help too. Fragrantica has a search-by-notes tool and shows similar perfumes on every listing. Parfumo offers detailed profiles with community-rated alternatives. Wikiparfum lets you search by ingredient, so you can find others built around the same materials. On Reddit’s r/fragrance, members regularly post recommendation threads where you can describe what you lost and ask what comes closest, and Basenotes, the longest-running fragrance forum, has decades of comparison discussions to search through.
Specialist boutiques can suggest scents in the same spirit.
Specialist perfume boutiques are worth a visit. Their staff know their collections well and can often suggest one or two scents in the same spirit; large department store counters rarely offer that depth. To explore on your own, a Discovery Set lets you try a range of scents on skin at home, and our Fragrance Finder suggests where to begin.
Your options at a glance
Option
01
Check it is really gone
Best when
Your usual shop no longer stocks it
Watch out for
Renamed, regional or reformulated versions
02
Buy the remaining stock
Best when
You love it and can find sealed bottles
Watch out for
Fakes, oxidised old stock, inflated prices
03
Find a similar perfume
Best when
You know its family and favourite notes
Watch out for
Judging on paper instead of skin
04
Create your own
Best when
You want a scent that is truly yours
Watch out for
Expecting an exact copy of the original
How to describe what you loved
Being able to put your perfume into words makes every other step easier, from asking a boutique for advice to creating your own. Think in three stages, as perfumers do: the top, heart and base notes. Was it the sparkle of bergamot in the first minutes, a creamy floral heart, or the soft musks and woods that stayed all day?
Then reach for textures and images rather than “nice” or “fresh”. Was it powdery or watery, smoky or milky, green like a snapped stem or warm like skin in the sun? Was it close to the body or did it fill a room? The more precise your words, the closer you will get.
04
Step 4
Can you create your own perfume instead?
Yes, and it is often the most rewarding answer. We will not copy another brand’s perfume, and no one should promise you that they can. What we can do is help you capture what you loved about it in a new creation that is entirely your own.
In our Luxe Blending Experience, a private session in our Perfumer’s Alcove in central London, one of our Blending Masters profiles your tastes, talks through what you loved about your old perfume, and guides you as you blend our Essentials into your own signature scent. You take home a full-size bottle, and we keep your blend so you can reorder it. Nobody can discontinue it on you.
If you would rather work at home, our Creation Sets let you experiment at your own pace. Read how to blend a fragrance to get started, and how to make your bespoke perfume if you want to go further.
Academy
Fundamentals of Perfume Creation: Foundation
Our semi-professional online course: study each fragrance family in depth and formulate its key accords, with a professional perfumer’s organ delivered to your home.
A perfume you create yourself is the one no brand can ever discontinue.
Frequently asked questions about discontinued perfumes
Why do perfumes get discontinued?
Mostly for commercial reasons: weak sales and limited shelf space. Changes in regulation and in brand ownership also play a part.
How can I tell if my perfume is discontinued or reformulated?
Ask the brand directly. A perfume may be renamed, sold only in some countries or in travel retail, or reformulated under the same name, which is why a new bottle can smell different.
Does old perfume go off?
Yes, slowly. Light, heat and air oxidise it, and the top notes suffer first: an old perfume can smell sharp, sour or flat, and the liquid may darken.
How should I store my last bottles?
Upright, with the cap on, in the box, somewhere cool and dark. Avoid the bathroom and sunny windowsills.
Can a discontinued perfume be recreated?
A laboratory analysis can approximate a formula but never reproduce it exactly, and copying another brand’s perfume raises ethical and legal issues. We do not copy perfumes; we help you create a new scent of your own inspired by what you loved.
How do I find a perfume similar to my discontinued one?
Identify its fragrance family and the notes you loved most, then test perfumes from the same family on your skin over several hours, not only on a paper strip.
Emmanuelle Moeglin is the founder and perfumer behind Experimental Perfume Club. Classically trained at ISIPCA, with 20 years in the fragrance industry, she is a member of the French Society of Perfumers, a multi-award-winning creator and a public speaker. She designs the brand’s blends and teaches perfumery from EPC’s central London studio.
